Another St John's Wort preparation shown to be better than placebo in major depression
The evidence base for use of St
John's Wort (SJW) in depression is improved by publication of this reasonably-sized
placebo-controlled trial, which found a significant benefit over placebo. A
difficulty in using SJW is that as a natural product with many different
preparations available, results from a clinical trial using one preparation
cannot necessarily be extrapolated to a different preparation; there are also
limited data on effective doses. This study aimed to compare the effect of two
different doses of SJW WS 5570 (a preparation previously compared to paroxetine
BMJ 2005; 330: 503) against placebo. It involved 332 patients with mild to
moderate major depression who were randomised in a 3:3:2 ratio to treatment with
SJW 600mg daily (n=123), 1200mg daily (n=127), or placebo (n=82). Standard
rating scales were used to measure the effect of treatment, and the primary
outcome was change in score on the HAM-D 17 scale. Study duration was six weeks,
and responders were offered continuation treatment in a 16-week double-blind
maintenance phase.
The results at six weeks showed improvement in all three groups, with a
significantly greater improvement in the SJW groups compared to placebo: HAM-D
17 score decreases were 11.6 (SJW 1200mg daily), 10.8 (SJW 600mg daily), and 6.0
(placebo), p<0.001 vs. placebo. Patients in the SJW groups also showed greater
improvements in secondary outcomes. All treatments were well tolerated, with
adverse events in the SJW groups being similar in incidence and consistent with
those known for SJW. Based on their results, the authors conclude that both
doses of SJW were safe and more effective than placebo in the treatment of mild
to moderate major depressive illness, with comparable efficacy for the two doses.
Resource link: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/4/14/abstract
![]()
Boletín de Actualización en
Neuropsicofarmacología (BAN)
Editor:
Luis I. Mariani
Para suscribirse enviar un e-mail en blanco a:
neuropsicofarmacologia-subscribe@gruposyahoo.com.ar
Número de
Suscriptos: 925
Mayor información sobre Psicofármacos
disponible en:
http:www.eutimia.com/psicofarmacos